Telling the stories of impunity and imprisonment of journalists worldwide
 
Eritrea's Lost Voices
Impunity
Imprisonment

Hassanpour & Botimar
KURDISTAN / IRAN

Subramaniyam Sukirtharajan
SRI LANKA

Slavko Curuvija
SERBIA

Omar Rodriguez Saludes
CUBA


Dawit Isaac

Emanuel Asrat
(Photo Amnesty International)

Dawit Habtemichael

Fessehaye Yohannes

Mattewos Habteab
(Photo: www.delina.org)

Medhanie Haile
(Photo: www.delina.org)

Said Abdulkader

Seyoum Tsehaye

 

 

Timeline

19 February 2009: IPI send letter to Eritrean President Isaias Afewerki: "'Sinister’ Detention of Journalists Must End".

12 November 2008: IPI launches its Justice Denied campaign calling for the release of Eritrean journalists, among other issues..

February 2007: Reports surface that Fesshaye "Joshua" Yohannes has succumbed to illness. Rumors of other deaths, including that of Said Abdulkader, Medhanie Haile and Yusuf Mohamed Ali also emerge.

November 2006: A second wave of arrests targets members of the state media. This includes Daniel Mussie and his colleague Tura Kubaba.

November 2005: Dawit Isaac is released for a medical check-up for two days, but subsequently returned to prison.

13 December 2002: According to some reports, Fessehaye "Joshua" Yohannes died as early as this date in a prison in Embatkala.

February 2002: Hamid Mohammed Said and Saleh Al Jezaeeri are arrested in Asmara.

September 2001: A broad political crackdown results in multiple arrests, including of many independent journalists. Dawit Isaac, Fessehaye "Joshua" Yohannes, Yusuf Mohamed Ali, Mattewos Habteab, Dawit Habtemichael, Medhanie Haile, Temesken Ghebreyesus, Emanuel Asrat, Seyoum Tsehaye and Fitzum Wedi Ade are all arrested at this time. Selamyinghes Beyene and Said Abdulkader are arrested shortly afterwards.

Mid-2000: Ghebrehiwet Keleta is arrested in Asmara.

1999: Zemenfes Haile is believed to have been arrested sometime during this year.

   
 

Read the article on Eritrea's Lost Voices in Tigrinya

Read the press release "New IPI Campaign Calls for Justice for Journalists Worldwide" in Tigrinya and in English

The Story

The most troubling fact about the journalists imprisoned in Eritrea is the dearth of available information. Targeted during two waves of journalist arrests carried out in September 2001 and November 2006, the group, currently said to total 18, has been little heard of ever since. Questions regarding their exact whereabouts and state of health abound.

Many were reportedly imprisoned at Eiraeiro, in the Northern Red Sea desert province, a notorious prison allegedly holding numerous political prisoners. News of the prison's existence emerged only in 2006, after several political prisoners died there. Conditions at the facility are said to be brutal, with inmates permanently manacled, forbidden from communicating with each other or with guards, and provided with little other than bread and vegetables to eat.

The exact number of those currently imprisoned remains unclear. Occasional individual sightings are reported, and several journalists are rumoured to have died in custody, some long ago.

The Arrests

The first crackdown occurred immediately after the 9/11 attacks on the United States. President Isaias Afwerki's government launched an assault on practically all of the young nation's critical voices, arresting hundreds of government opponents, shutting down every independent media outlet and arresting independent journalists on sight, all in the name of combating terrorism. The arrests were said to be motivated by an effort to eliminate political dissent ahead of elections, which were scheduled for December 2001 but subsequently cancelled without explanation. Approximately eight to 12 journalists were imprisoned and, a few months later, transferred to undisclosed locations after going on hunger strike.

The second wave of arrests took place in November of 2006 and focused on journalists working for the state media, with nine journalists detained, apparently to intimidate state media workers after several colleagues had fled the country. Some were subsequently released, although they were followed and their phones were tapped; they were also forced to return to work and expressly forbidden from leaving the capital, Asmara.

The Journalists

As of late 2008, the following journalists are believed to remain imprisoned, and some are feared dead. Please click on the individual names for more information about these journalists.

Dawit Isaac, journalist, co-founder of Setit, Eritrea's first independent newspaper

Fessehaye "Joshua" Yohannes (Johannes), journalist, co-founder of Setit, Eritrea's first independent newspaper

Yusuf (Yosuf) Mohamed Ali, editor-in-chief of Tsigenay (Tsegenay)

Mattewos Habteab, co-founder and editor of Meqaleh

Dawit Habtemichael, co-founder and assistant editor-in-chief of Meqaleh

Medhanie Haile, co-founder and assistant chief editor of Keste Debena

Temesken (Temesgen) Ghebreyesus (Gebreyesus), sports reporter for Keste Debena

Emanuel (Amanuel)(Emmanuel) Asrat, editor of Zemen

Said Abdulkader, editor and founder of Admas

Seyoum Tsehaye, director of Eritrean state television, freelance editor and photographer

Hamid Mohammed Said, news and sports editor, Eritrean state television

Saleh Al Jezaeeri (Al-Jezaeri), reporter for Eritrean state radio, as well as for a government newspaper

Fitzum Wedi Ade, assistant editor with Zemen

Selamyinghes Beyene, reporter for Meqaleh,

Zemenfes Haile, founder and manager of Tsigenay

Ghebrehiwet (Gebrehiwot) Keleta, reporter for Tsigenay

Daniel Mussie, Radio Dimtsi Hafash

Tura Kubaba, Radio Dimtsi Hafash

Recent Developments

Information has been sparse, but the little news that emerged was ominous. In February 2007, reports surfaced that Fesshaye "Joshua" Yohannes had succumbed to illness. According to several recent estimates, as many as three other journalists may also have died in custody, possibly as early as 2005 or 2006. They include Said Abdulkader of Admas; Medhanie Haile of Keste Debena; and Yusuf Mohamed Ali of Tsigenay. The others remain in jail, held incommunicado and without charge or access to legal representation.

IPI and other press freedom and human rights organisations have repeatedly called on the Eritrean government to release these journalists, and at the very least to specify their whereabouts, ensure their health and permit them access to both family members and legal representatives.

Disappointingly, the international community's response has been fairly muted, particularly in Europe, where once relatively forceful criticism has recently waned. European development officials have made no public mention of the detainees during recent visits to the country. In the meantime, Eritrea's governmental leaders have consistently ignored appeals, instead insisting that the journalists were jailed not for their critical writings, but for "undermining the sovereignty and national security of Eritrea".

 

Related Links:

>> IPI 19 February 2009 statement: "Sinister’ Detention of Journalists Must End, IPI Tells Eritrean Leader"

>> IPI 2008 World Press Freedom Review: Overview of Africa

>> IPI 10 July 2007 Appeal for the Resease of Imprisoned Eritrean Journalists
Appeal to H.E. José Manuel Durão Barroso, President of the European Commission, H.E. Robert Zoellick, President of the World Bank, and H.E. Douglas Alexander MP, UK Secretary of State for International Development, urging them to use their good contacts with the Eritrean government to convince it to release the imprisoned journalists

>> IPI 8 April 2002 statement on Eritrean government’s inhumane treatment of independent journalists working within the country

What IPI has done so far:
What You Can Do: